Huntington, NY, is known for its charming atmosphere, rich history, and a thriving culinary scene that’s bound to satisfy any palate. From cozy cafés to elegant dining experiences, the restaurants near Huntington serve up a diverse array of dishes that showcase the best of local flavors. Whether you're in the mood for a fresh seafood platter, a hearty steak, or a vegan feast, there's something for everyone. Let’s explore some of the top restaurants near Huntington, NY, that are ideal for any occasion, each offering its own unique dining experience.
Oyster Bay Brewing Company
If you’re a fan of craft beer and good food, Oyster Bay Brewing Company is a must-visit. Located just a short drive from Huntington, this brewery is famous not only for its innovative and locally brewed beers but also for its delicious food offerings. The menu here is filled with hearty, flavorful dishes like fresh seafood, BBQ, and seasonal specialties. The relaxed atmosphere makes it a great spot to hang out with friends or family while enjoying some of Long Island’s best craft brews.
- Great with: Signature beers paired with lobster rolls or a brisket burger.
- Vibe: Casual, lively, and local.
La Casa Cafe
For those seeking authentic Italian flavors, La Casa Cafe in nearby East Northport is a hidden gem. Expect homestyle cooking, a cozy, intimate atmosphere, and an extensive wine list. From classics like spaghetti and meatballs to seafood ravioli, every dish highlights fresh ingredients and careful preparation—ideal for a date night or special celebration.
- Must-try: Seafood ravioli & tiramisu.
- Vibe: Warm, intimate, and welcoming.
H2O Seafood & Sushi
Seafood lovers should head to H2O Seafood & Sushi in Smithtown. With chic décor and waterfront views, H2O balances upscale presentation with a relaxed feel. The menu features ocean-inspired dishes such as perfectly seared scallops, lobster bisque, and a rotating selection of oysters, with a focus on fresh, sustainable sourcing.
- Best for: Special occasions and seafood cravings.
- Order: Lobster bisque & oysters.
Ralph’s Italian Ices & Ice Cream
In the mood for something sweet? Ralph’s Italian Ices & Ice Cream is a beloved local stop for handmade ices and ice cream. With a wide range of flavors—from chocolate and vanilla to fruit-forward favorites like mango—it’s the perfect family-friendly treat after a day around town.
- Good to know: Italian ices are especially refreshing on warm days.
Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar
For a polished night out, Prime: An American Kitchen & Bar pairs a sophisticated menu—think prime steaks, seafood, and modern American fare—with panoramic views of Huntington Harbor. It’s an elegant pick for date nights, anniversaries, or any evening when you want dinner to feel like an event.
- Standouts: Filet mignon & lobster tail.
- Vibe: Upscale, scenic, celebratory.
Mamma Lombardi’s of Holbrook
Experience classic Italian hospitality at Mamma Lombardi’s of Holbrook. Known for generous portions and a wide-ranging menu—from fresh pasta and wood-fired pizza to seafood and steaks—it’s a reliable choice for family dinners or festive gatherings.
- Good for: Group dinners & celebrations.
The Capital Grille
For a refined steakhouse experience, The Capital Grille in Garden City delivers polished service, an elegant setting, and expertly prepared dry-aged steaks alongside fresh seafood. Pair your entrée with a selection from the extensive wine list for a truly elevated meal.
- Favorites: Bone-in ribeye & lobster bisque.
The Milleridge Inn
Steeped in history, The Milleridge Inn in Jericho serves homestyle American comfort food in a cozy, old-world setting that shines during the holidays. Classic dishes—roast turkey, prime rib, and homemade pies—make it a nostalgic favorite for family gatherings.
- Vibe: Historic, festive, and family-friendly.
Dig In at the Best Dining Spots Near Huntington
Huntington and its neighboring towns boast a vibrant, diverse dining scene—from fresh seafood and Italian classics to modern American cuisine and frozen delights. The next time you’re planning a meal out, explore these standout spots and savor the local flavors.
Make the drive as memorable as the meal. Arrive in comfort and style with a new Audi from Audi of Huntington. Our team can help you find the perfect vehicle for all your culinary adventures.
Categories:
Local Guide
